
ran into this quote from
desert preacher:
People are getting sick and tired of hearing about “candles, coffee, and conversation.” If that’s the best the EC can muster, it’s doomed.
i live on the far edge of the emerging world, often wondering if my blue collar, homeless, youth and rock/punk universe really interplays well with the rest of the church. we have, over the years, flirted with modernity and post-modernity. years ago we idolized the willow wonder and the purpose driven pizzaz, eventually abandoning each for what we considered a purer, more authentic experience within the margins of the poe-moe framework. people like
jordon cooper, the folks at the
ooze, and others have helped us come out of the closet, given us permission to be who we are. i still remember clearly my first taste of post-modernism in its polished form at Mt. Herman Conference Center, back in the day. i found that i wasn't an anomely, that the stirrings and frustrations i had intrinsically felt with the church growth movement were not in fact aberrations. it was a liberating experience to find other paid religionists as screwed up as i was.
like all of us who do this for a living i have oft fallen into the trap of seeking uber solutions to my pastoring woes which promised to transform my life with little or no understanding. just inflict a drama into your service and presto, willow world. the people will undoubtedly flock to church. although i didn't realize it at the time, i soon employed the same tactics with my post-modernist freedom as well. it became about the candles, the lighting, celtic prayers and recitations, gotees and video (i have over 60 gigs of video in my library, arguably the largest collection of video for the church in canada). though it was taboo to be completely honest with ourselves and others, the trend was still about copying, still about 'flash and ash'. still about impressing the unchurched. still about performance.
some time ago i had a conversation with a self-proclaimed expert on post-modern church who informed me, in smug tones, that my service wasn't 'post-modern enough'. though i didn't say anything at the time, it made me laugh later. there was still the assumption that emerging churches:
- use accoustic guitars and better music
- must have candles and icons to be effective
- must change up the service format (though never admit we have one) weekly
- use poetry and quote from dead guys
- employ video projectors and slides
- love the "stations of the cross"
- dress "down"
- like beer and red wine
- swear
- denegrate the modern church
- form elitist affiliations
- have a rock band
- love secondary lighting
- draw pictures, paint crap, have stations all over the room
- draw a labyrinth on your floor
- and are generally a bunch of wounded, whiney ex youth pastors that no one understands.
... the list goes on and on. a subtle form of elitism had begun to filter in. we developed our own gurus and still worshipped on the alter of success, though we redefined what that was. smaller was better, house churches were superior to worship services, young beat out old, self-effacement was cooler than dynamic preaching, quotes from dead people were better than thots from old people. we began to name our churches and our services after cool hebrew words. we started to paint in church.
for a while it seemed so fresh.
later it just got lame.
and we know it. so we jump on the next train to glory and still sit in groups on a saturday nite trying to figure out how we can make the next event cooler than the last. and the trap tightens.
lately i have had an opportunity to sit back and question my own motivations in this regard. i decided not to be involved in any poe-moe mega-events this year, not to line up my team of v.j.'s and borrow 12 video projectors, not to spend endless hours previewing the lately coldplay videos for clips and hooks. i sat back with an old acrostic i learned years ago and re-evaluated where my dreams were going. it was the old "epic" acrostic - aged and outdated, unvogue.
i asked myself if my faith and my church was "
experiential". did we experience god? were all the videos and the tricks helping or hindering the metaphysical? some of them were just becoming traps. the candles were now meaningless. 12 videos in the service seemed to have become more of a distraction than a blessing. it was chaotic and cool, but was it godly?
and was it
participatory at all? it seemed god's people were just as inclined to be spectators as they were at willow creek. they still loved the glitz and the guitar solo. they still wanted to know who was speaking which week. but were they being transformed? were they a part of the holy narrative? even when we made them participate was it because they wanted to be in front of the pack? they were beginning to minister but were they transformed? i didn't know.
sure we had lots of
images for an image-based world but were they helping people to imagine god, or were they only entertaining?
were we building
community any better than we used to?
i put away the dumb acrostic and sat back and asked myself about myself. did the people know my brokenness but also know the healing? was i being real and raw or just raw? was there a sense of holiness that we as a church desired or were we glorying in our weakness? was i faking it?
it is rather humorous for me to read the critiques that spew out constantly about the liberalism of the emerging church. the "fact" that we no longer believe in the authority of scripture. they don't get it. not even a bit. most of us are conservative by most standards but all they can see is that we question orthodoxy and drink beer. the reason i found a home in this movement was because of the authenticity; the inability to accept carte-blanche the excuses and tired legalism of the past; the desire to rediscover our spiritual heart. let the others fear for our souls, it concerns me not at all. they don't get it. they only see the slippery slope to liberalism and misunderstand the intentions and the realities of those of us who are honest enough to question. i only hope that as the emerging church hits mainstream that some of us will still keep our crap detectors on stun and not forget why we found a home in the first place. candles are lame. country music is just as appropriate as gregorian chants though i rarely listen to either. most of us finger paint better than we draw epic icons. gotees look ugly. changing the service format every week is too much work, and for what? Most of my video isn't as good as "family guy" anyway. i hate accoustic guitars. most old poems suck. chicks dig a sharp dressed guy. i despise most hymns. the labyrinth bores me now. wine makes me gag. who really cares anyway, these things are meaningless in and of themselves - just gimics.
it's about the heart, the healing, the honesty, integrity and yes - even balance. it was about re-imagining our love for god. i hope we don't lose that as we begin to publish books and swap super cool videos.