warning: this is politically incorrect.
already the rush of festivities, if one may use that term, are gearing up to remember september 11, 2001. like most of us, i can remember well where i was that morning. a good friend and i had flown down to LA on september 10, for some time of reflection and beach. little did we realize the change that morning would bring to our schedule, let alone the world as we knew it.
this weekend millions of people will spend some time reflecting on that event. hardly anyone will spend any time thinking about the 80,000+ iraqi casualties that are connected forever (though many of us struggle to see the connection) to that event.
some years ago i stood at a memorial to another watershed event in history - pearl harbour. as i meandered through the exhibit i was struck but the incredibly idealistic rewriting of history, as presented by the tour guide. the largely american audience was regaled with sentimental drival concerning the loss of human life. though i can appreciate the sacrifice made on that day, though i mourn the loss of any human life, many of us do not see pearl harbour as a senseless loss.
pearl harbour saved millions of lives. that some 1400+ people died in this tragedy is a horrible thing. compared, however, to the sacrifice made by thousands of other americans, by millions and millions of europeans, canadians and russians, this loss is minimal. already the americans were years late in entering the war. though their president had done what he felt he could to help the war effort in a political hotbed, the continued reluctance of the american politicians to declare war cost countless lives.
pearl harbour afforded the americans the excuse to enter the war; ultimately helping to turn the tide, shorten the conflict, and ensure that we all do not speak german. it can be argued that had the americans not entered the war that germany, if they could resolve the russian issue, would have easily destroyed the american military once he had the resources in place.
it diminishes the sacrifice of those who gave their lives at pearl harbour by declaring what happened to be merely an unfortunate tragedy. their sacrifice saved the lives of many lives, albeit european and asian lives.
which brings me full circle back to the events surrounding 9/11. like all civilized people i believe that what happened on that day was more than tragic. that innocent civilians could be sacrificed to the fortunes of political conflict is inexcusable. i wonder, however, how choked up we would be had those been merely iraqi or somalian or rwandian lives... if they had not been predominately middle-class, white, north american lives. some hundreds of people die in a flood in the states and it is seen as an international tragedy. thousands die in the same way in a mid-eastern country and it barely makes the news. thousands of innocent iraqis die because of american foreign policy and you have to search the net to find out the casualty lists. imagine the outcry, just try to imagine it, if 80 or 100,000 americans or canadians died by foreign political will.
this weekend, as i reflect on the horror of 9/11 i intend to take a moment or two to pray for those expendable iraqi citizens who daily face the horror of loss of life and unimaginable violence.
for those who suffer by the millions in african countries where there is no oil to liberate.