i was nervous. we had worked for a long time on this project and 7:30 was quickly approaching... and no one was coming.
i grew up in the church growth movement. i remember, in vivid detail, the rallies, the denominational pushes, the cheasy campaigns ("1000 by 2000!"). regardless of what was being said privately, numbers were all that mattered. the denominational superintendent wanted monthly tally sheets. the fastest growing churches were featured in print and public.
i know of what i speak. i was one of those churches. at one point i had the fastest growing church plant in north america. magazines would call, there would be phone interviews, and the denomination looked for excuses to feature the church.
but it never seemed to be enough. i somehow thought that i would be happy. finally i was beginning to see some results. my insecure ego was being stroked. i was a big fish in a small bowl.
but for some reason i wasn't happy. if only we could grow to the next level, break the next barrier, then i would have 'made it'. we studied the binders on "breaking the 200 barrier", then the one on the 400 barrier, then the one on the 1000 barrier. it seemed that success was constantly just over the horizon. we had enormous outreach events, we talked to consultants, we strategized numbers with the church growth expert. i've been there.
if there is anything i have learned in the past years it is this subtle philosophical maxim - the church growth movement sucks. powered by our need to succeed and driven by greed, it is a psychotic rollercoaster of insecurity and pain. it robbed the joy out of the moment, every moment. sundays became about who was not there, not who was. our motivations became suspect, our desires twisted.
the church growth movement, though it served a purpose, destroyed the hearts and egos of a generation of pastors. the trail of broken dreams and feelings of inadequacy stretches out as far as the eye can see. if you were to talk to some of the pastors and leaders that i have you would find them joyless and frustrated.
so last night the clubchurch opened. maybe 40 people showed up and half of those were well-wishers, friends and spies. i expect next week to be smaller yet.
yes we will continue to advertise. yes we will work hard. but for some reason i can't find the motivation for mass marketing and kamikaze advertising that i used to live or die by. bigger no longer feels better. i want to be effective, i want to make a difference, but something has changed inside of me.
i was nervous last night. threw up as usual. but i also had fun. fun at church. it's been a long time.
i genuinely like the people i'm on this project with. they aren't "parishioners". we are all volunteers. after expenses i came home with 5 bucks and some nickels for next week's float.
i want real. i want community. i want cappuccino.